Top 10 most valuable Canadian coins sold at auction in 2022
By thecanadiannumismatist | Monday, 14 November 2022
Here's the Top 10 most valuable Canadian coins sold at auction in 2022 so far. Prices are in Canadian currency.
#1 - $119,500 - 50 cents 1921 - PCGS SP-62
Canada's 1921 fifty-cent piece is a very rare coin; fewer than 200 are believed to exist. This is a direct result of the great variation in demand for fifty-cent pieces since their introduction in Canada in 1870. This SP-62 example was previously described by Stack's Bowers:
Beautiful dusty rose toning embraces the surfaces and design alike displaying brilliant iridescent highlights and excellent eye appeal.
#2 - $46,440 - 10 dollars 1912 - PCGS SP-69
In 2019, a PCGS SP-68 example sold for $30,345. This SP-69 example was described by Heritage Auctions:
The 1912 Canadian Specimens are comparably more obtainable than most other years; yet, when encountered in this elite preservation, their rarity increases tenfold as does their appeal to grade-conscious collectors.
Learn more about the $5 and $10 dollars gold coins »
#3 - $36,746 - 50 cents 1932 - PCGS MS-66
Another half dollar 1932, ICCS MS-65, sold at auction in November 2022 for $22,705.
#4 - $36,447.50 - 10 cents 1886 Large Knobbed 6 - PCGS MS-65
#5 - $31,106 - 50 cents 1905 - ICCS - MS-63
This half dollar sold at the same auction as the 1932 example on this list. Only 40,000 examples of this coin were produced. This particular coin is listed as MS-62 on PCGS website, but marked as MS-63 at the The Canadian Numismatic Company auction.
In 2019, another PCGS MS-63 piece from the George Hans Cook Collection of Canadian Coinage, sold for $55,902.
#6 - $30,472 - 25 cents 1875H - PCGS - MS-62
One of only 5 Mint State examples known to exist, this coin sold in January 2022.
#7 - $29,875 - 5 cents 1921 - PCGS - MS-63
In 1921, a legislation was passed to remove silver 5-cent coins and replace them with 21mm (instead 15.5mm) 100% nickel ones. At that time, the Mint melted more than 3 million of silver five cents coins which most of them were from 1921. Only 400 silver 5-cents coins are believed to have survived. Considered The Prince of Canadian Coinage.
#8 - $28,956 - 2 dollars 1865 Newfoundland - PCGS - SP-64
Like all other British North American colonies, Newfoundland adopted, in the mid-19th century, a decimal currency. However, in introducing the new currency in 1865, Newfoundland, unlike other colonies, chose to include a gold coin among the denominations it was issuing.
#9 - $24,660 - Holey Dollar - NGC - F-15
Some 1,000 Spanish Milled Dollars were officially pierced and countermarked; the pierced coins were over-valued as 5 Shillings, while the cut-out centers were under-valued as Shillings. Since the actual silver value of the latter was greater than its new denomination, most of them vanished from circulation. A thousand pierced pieces were insufficient to relieve the prevailing shortage and prominent area merchants privately added to the supply, agreeing to receive their version of the Holey Dollar at par with the government issue. Official circulation ceased in September 1814, though local merchants continued to accept the pieces for a few more years.
#10 - $24,576 - Gold Sovereign 1908C - PCGS - SP-64
Only 636 examples were struck in 1908, all of which are Specimen strikings. Because the Ottawa Mint was a branch of the Royal Mint in 1908, it was part of the duty to produce Gold Sovereign for London. The mintmark C above the date stands for Canada.
#11 - $24,500 - 10 cents 1875H - ICCS - MS-64
#12 - $20,315 - 20 cents 1871 - ICCS - SP-65
Most patterns, essays and trials were not approved for release, but produced to evaluate a proposed coin design, new or revised coinage, to test the metal composition, dies, structure of the coin, etc.
Pictures by Heritage Auctions, PCGS and The Canadian Numismatic Company.
Related numismatic tools, articles and links
- Canadian coins
- Canadian banknotes
- Canadian tokens and medals
You can submit your own articles by contacting us.